Zisk #25 is out!

It's been a lengthy delay for this issue for various reasons, but our fall issue is finally in the mail! Subscribers should have a copy in their mailbox by the end of the week.

Zisk # 25

The Cincinnati Cycle by Shawn Abnoxious

Ten Top Ten Lists by Abby and Jesse Mendelson

On Wrigley's 100th, A Lesson in What Really Matters by R. Lincoln Harris

The Waldwick Batboy Trials by Joe Evans

John "The Hammer" Milner by Tim Hinely

Zisk Book Review Corner by Mark Hughson and Steve Reynolds

The Metsian (In)Perfection of 2014 by Mike Faloon

The Cincinnati Cycle by Shawn Abnoxious

It's July as I write this. George Vogel, a Cincinnati Standard reporter and sports anchor for local 12 News at Eleven announced that the Cincinnati Bengals training camp opens tomorrow. Yeah, I know, this is Zisk, a baseball magazine, but the training camp announcement couldn't have came at a worse time. The Cincinnati Reds are at a season low. Everybody—well, not everybody, but actually my Dad said Votto wasn't going to be the same after that knee-thingy and he was right.

It seems that despite a lot of players on the disabled list, things were looking up before the all-star game. I was actually warming up to the new manager Bryan Price, after the nasty surprise ousting of Dusty Baker. Then, in true Cincinnati professional sports fashion, everything fell apart.

You see, with the Bengals Training Camp starting-up, Cincinnatians have/will call it done with the Reds season and get 'all-about' football. That will last until the Bengals fuck-up and then talk of the Reds spring training begins and the vicious cycle begins again. The Bengals are ditched for hopes of the Reds next season. I call this The Cincinnati Cycle.

I know it’s harsh, but it's how this city’s run. We Cincinnatians are fair-weather evil bastards that are ready in a moment’s notice to throw whoever they have to under a bus or fucking street-car. We're fickle like that. We're not in it for the long-haul. Cincinnati fans are eager for championships! World Series and Super Bowl victories and all it's surrounding hoopla. We mean business.

On this fateful night of July 23, even before anyone said anything on the news, you could see it on the Reds’ faces already! It was over. Channel 12's George Vogel and his announcement of Bengals Training Camp just gave the jar a lid. In an after-game interview Bryan Price hinted at a possible turn-around after an off-day before a series at Great American Ballpark. A turn-around would be nice. That's a nice dream to have and hold onto. That's the sort of dream you build a wall around. Whereas there's still definitely room for a really tremendously awesome comeback, it's not going to happen. Trust me. Trust my

Dad.

I watched the highlights and those Brewers, those fucking Brewers, just won the physical victory as well as the mental victory. Price would dare not admit it but he knows. George Vogel knows. My Dad, watching from the foothills of the Appalachian Mountains, in the back bedroom of an add-on trailer, watching a 15" LED flatscreen knows. I know. Now you know! Someone's got to win, and someone's got to lose. That's where the Reds enter the equation.

I'm always going to be a Reds fan and will never forget my decision to start watching Cincinnati Reds games so my Dad and I would have something to talk about besides how well my car was running and when I was going to get the oil changed. I'm glad to have made that decision. I don't follow the Bengals the way I follow the Reds despite the mental similarities that both teams seem to have. I suppose, that really, truth be told, following theReds and to a verily lesser extent, the fucking Bengals, we, the collective we, we are Cincinnati! We are Greater Cincinnati and we have learned the valuable lesson of defeat, failure and more importantly moving-on.

All of these lessons are hard to face but are essential for living here and becoming proud, bitchy Cincinnatians. There's only going to be one champion and right off the bat, no one’s chances looks good. Everybody is a potential loser whether it's admitted or not. Welcome to Cincinnati, we've been waiting for you.

I realize now, after all these words, that I thought I was better than all of this. I thought I was a much bigger fan, a more loyal fan, than to just give up so soon after the allstar break. Long before there's talk of a “magic number” but truly, I'm not. I admit it! I'm a product of my environment and a slave to my ingrained Southwestern Ohio doom-culture. I'm from Cincinnati! I am Cincinnati! I'm gonna go call my Dad who will agree and solidify my newfound admissions with a phone conversation that will last less than a minute. My Dad on the phone, is all killer and no filler. He will verify that for the 2014 season, The Reds are DONE.

So, 'fuck-it'. Let's move-on. We are Cincinnati so you don't have to be.

Ten Top Ten Lists by Abby and Jesse Mendelson

Who doesn't love a baseball Top Ten List? Here are a few of ours, all in alphabetical order, born of endless hours in the car, driving to every major league ballpark – twice.

Top Ten Nicknames

What would the Grand Old Game be without colorful monikers?

Dennis “Old Can” Boyd

Jay Hanna “Dizzy” Dean/Paul Dee "Daffy" Dean

Adam "Big Donkey" Dunn

Mark "The Bird" Fydrich

Rich “El Guapo” Garces

"Shoeless" Joe Jackson

Walter "Big Train" Johnson

Charles Edwin "Tug" McGraw

Frank "The Big Hurt" Thomas

Paul "Big Poison" Waner/Lloyd "Little Poison" Waner

Honorable Mention: Burt “Be Home By Eleven” Blyleven

Top Ten Tubs of Lard Who Should Be Embarrassed to Wear a Baseball Uniform

Seriously, these guys have the crust to call themselves professional athletes?

Big Fat Bartolo Colon (h/t Matthew Berry)

Prince Fielder

Willie Horton

John Kruk

Mickey Lolich

Dave Parker (when his weight ballooned to 260+)

Boog Powell

George Herman Ruth (in his later years)

David Wells

Hack Wilson

Honorable Mention: Philip Seymour Hoffman as the reed-thin Art Howe in Moneyball

Top Ten Players You'd Want to Take the Field in the Ninth Inning of the Seventh Game of the World Series

The ultimate winners to win the ultimate game

Johnny Bench, C

Lou Gehrig, 1B

Rogers Hornsby, 2B

Brooks Robinson, 3B

Honus Wagner, SS

Jackie Robinson, LF

Joe DiMaggio, CF

Roberto Clemente, RF

Sandy Koufax, SP

Mariano Rivera, RP

Pinch Hitter: Joe Morgan

Top Ten Players Who Should Be Bounced from the Hall of Fame

These happy recipients of cronyism, sub standards, and should be given their walking papers

Orlando Cepeda

Bobby Doerr (being old friends with Teddy Ballgame will open doors)

Johnny Evers (being part of a famous poem will open doors)

Billy Herman

Monte Irvin

Tony Lazzeri (being old friends with Babe Ruth will open doors)

Rabbit Maranville

Jim Rice (being old friends with Jerry Lewis will open doors)

Phil Rizzuto (being old friends with Yogi Berra will open doors)

Ron Santo (being old friends with Ernie Banks will open doors)

Honorable Mention: Tony Perez (if only because it is the single biggest division between Abby and Jesse. The former keeps him in; the latter chucks him out.)

Top Ten People Who Should Be Elected to the Hall of Fame

These unhappy victims of hypocrisy, shortsightedness and double standards should be enshrined immediately

Barry Bonds

Roger Clemens

Gus Greenlee

Joe Jackson

Mark McGwire

Buck O'Neill

Rafael Palmeiro

Tim Raines

Pete Rose

Sammy Sosa

Honorable Mention: Jeff Bagwell

Top Ten Wasted Talents

There's nothing sadder than thinking about what might have been. Here are some glorious ballplayers who, for one reason or another, tripped, stumbled, and fell on their putative way to Cooperstown

Billy Beane

Cesar Cedeno

J.D. Drew

Dwight Gooden

Jeff King

Ben McDonald

Dave Parker

Darryl Strawberry

Brien Taylor

Garry Templeton

Honorable Mention: Matt Bush

Top Ten Elbow Benders

Unfortunately, baseball has known far more than its fair share of gents with too generous a taste for the gargle

Grover Cleveland Alexander

Wade Boggs

Big Ed Delahanty

Ryne Duren

Ellis Kinder

Sam McDowell

Mickey Mantle

Billy Martin

Babe Ruth

David Wells

Honorable Mention: Dock Ellis, because we don’t have an LSD category

Top Ten Cokeheads

And the Swingin' Seventies' drug of choice, too

Dennis “Oil Can” Boyd

Dwight Gooden

Keith Hernandez

Steve Howe

Amos Otis

Dave Parker

Tim Raines

Rod Scurry

Darryl Strawberry

Willie Wilson

Honorable Mention: Dale Berra

Top Ten Truly Bad Baseball Acting Performances

We know that Robert Redford (The Natural) and Kevin Costner (Bull Durham and For Love of the Game) really were athletes, so they come off…OK. But while playing ballplayers is irresistible, it is also terribly difficult. Pretending to be an athlete means really walking the walk, which only real athletes can do. Of a huge list, some truly egregious performances:

William Bendix (Babe Ruth, The Babe Ruth Story)

Gary Cooper (Lou Gehrig, The Pride of the Yankees)

John Goodman (Babe Ruth, The Babe)

Tommy Lee Jones (Ty Cobb, Cobb)

Ray Liotta (Shoeless Joe Jackson, Field of Dreams)

Michael Moriarty (Henry Wiggins)/Robert DeNiro (Bruce

Pearson, Bang the Drum

Anthony Perkins (Jimmy Piersall, Fear Strikes Out)

Ronald Reagan (Grover Cleveland Alexander, The

Winning Team)

Tim Robbins (Nuke LaLoosh, Bull Durham)

David Strathairn (Eddie Cicotte, Eight Men Out)

Honorable Mention: Tab Hunter (Shoeless Joe Hardy, Damn Yankees!). Yes, we know it was supposed to be a comedy, but puh-lease!

Top Ten Acrobats

Chicks may dig the long ball, but we relish—and remember—those who made the impossible plays look

easy, and part of their regular repertoire

Johnny Bench

Roberto Clemente (just ask Merv Rettenmund)

Keith Hernandez

Andruw Jones

Jose “Chico” Lind

Bill Mazeroski

Andrew McCutchen

Rey Ordonez

Brooks Robinson

Ozzie Smith

Honorable Mention: Willie Howard Mays, who made every routine play seem as if it were the hardest grab in baseball history

All of this, of course, is up for debate. Enjoy!

Abby Mendelson is a writer and educator in Pittsburgh whose books include histories of the Pittsburgh Steelers, Pittsburgh neighborhoods and houses of worship, among others.

Jesse Mendelson, his son, is a healthcare consultant in Washington, D.C., skilled baseball historian like his dad, and highly successful fantasy player.

On Wrigley's 100th, A Lesson in What Really Matters by R. Lincoln Harris

As a society, we like round numbers. The 40^th anniversary of Hank Aaron's 715th home run was duly celebrated this year, but don't look for anything similar to it until the 50th anniversary in 2024. The same thing goes for any significant events from 1974, 1984, 1989, 1994 (20th anniversary of the players' strike, anyone?) and 2004. Those events will be dusted off and remembered this year, and will then go back into mothballs to make room for next year's anniversaries.

But 100 years is a big deal. For starters, it virtually guarantees that nobody is alive with any memory of the event taking place to begin with. People might live to be 100, but their memories don't usually kick in until the age of five or six, and by the time they make it to 105 or 106, well, let's say nature will assert itself first.

But the second reason why 100 years is a big deal is that it won't be commemorated again until year 125 or maybe year 150. So enjoy the commemoration, certainly, but realize that anniversaries number 101 through 124, at least, will be summarily ignored.

With the 100-year anniversary of Wrigley Field—even if the Cubs didn't yet play there and the park had a different name—it was the second time in three years that a ballpark reached the century mark, as Fenway Park did so back in 2012. But another ballpark centennial won't happen until Dodger Stadium in 2062, which is nearly a half-century away. So chances are that we won't see another such celebration in our lifetimes, and this one had better count.

Day games in the middle of the week are a rare treat at Wrigley Field. Night games once happened in a very haphazard manner, but recently it has broken down into night games on Mondays, Tuesdays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays, and day games on Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays. With that in mind, it's rare that I get to listen to a Cubs game on the radio as I'm driving home from work. But the centennial day was an exception—a day game on a Wednesday—and I felt very good as I left the office in the afternoon.

The Cubs had opened up a 5-2 lead over the Arizona Diamondbacks, who had reverted to calling themselves the "Packers" to honor the visiting team for the 1914 opener at Weeghman Park in Chicago. The game was played in the new Federal League, and Chicago's entry was known as the Chi-Feds. The Cubs sported throwback uniforms with "Feds" on them, to get more into the 1914 groove. So from this moment on, the action will be between the Feds (Cubs) and Packers (D-Backs).

When I got into my car to begin the commute home, the Feds still held a 5-4 lead, but their closer, Pedro Strop, was struggling. What I did not know was that their setup man—a concept that would have been utterly nonsensical to the actual Chi-Feds—had pitched a supremely efficient eighth inning, needing only six pitches to retire the side. After taking over for Feds starter Jeff Samardzija. But this is still the Tony LaRussa era of bullpen management, which means that the designated closer gets to start the ninth inning with a fresh slate.

A leadoff walk is usually a bad sign, and the Feds got one in the ninth inning. Throw in a fielding error and another walk, and the home team found itself in a spot that it could not escape from. The Feds' closer did not get a called strike on a two-strike pitch, and the Packers were able to tie the game up with a single, and then push the eventual winning runs across on what the announcer described (and I'm not kidding) as a "pop-fly triple" to right field. Only the Feds could lose in such stunning fashion.

By the time the home team had lost, my mind was numb. On a day loaded with historical significance, the second century of the old ballpark had been launched in the most horrific way imaginable. I picked up my phone, and was intending to post a Facebook message saying "Painful. There's no other word for it." I had the message in mind, and it was only a matter of a few keystrokes to share my grief with others of a similar disposition.

But what I saw upon opening my Facebook account stopped me cold. A student of mine, from the days when I taught Social Studies in the Chicago Public Schools in the late 1990s, had died suddenly. He was in his early 30s, and I had not seen or heard from him since he walked across the stage at graduation back in the summer of 2000. But still, I have friended a number of his former classmates in the years since then, and the news of his passing was so much of a shock that the result of a baseball game seemed terribly unimportant.

Instead of typing out my disappointment with the Feds, I offered words of encouragement to his family and friends on Facebook, and vowed to hug my own family even tighter than usual when I saw them that evening. To do anything else would have felt disrespectful.

Some people claim that they "live and die" with their team, but that clearly is not true. People "live and live" with their team, instead. If their team wins, that's great, but the sun will still come up the next morning. And when their team loses it sucks and it's disappointing, but the sun is still going to come up the next morning, all the same.

The truth is that it's only a game, folks. It's not actually life and death, what happens out there on a baseball field. The unfortunate thing is that it took an actual incidence of life and death to make this clear to me. And it's a lesson that I'll hopefully carry with me for the rest of my days.

This piece is dedicated to the memory of Adonis Jones (1982-2014).